“Gel Eyeliner Battle: Product Review”

Eyeliner is definitely a part of my daily look for the past years. If there is one product that I can’t live without, I will certainly choose eyeliner. Over the years, I tried a lot of brands and kinds of eyeliners in the market. Gel based eyeliner is my current favorite since this product lasts longer than the pencil eyeliners.

I have tried a few different brands of gel eyeliners so I thought I would share a review of these products to hopefully help you guys find the best gel eyeliner.

*Stila Smudge Pot

This is a very interesting product that’s why I picked it among all other liners at Sephora because it is an eyeliner and eye shadow in one bottle. It is very long lasting, waterproof and doesn’t crease but I was really disappointed with this product. The color is more of a greyish black which is the first disappointment since I prefer really dark liners. The product also dried out after just a month even if I was using it everyday and the consistency turned very flaky which made me stop using it completely. I will probably not repurchase this product and would give it a 1 out of 5 score.

*Maybelline Eyestudio

This is the first drugstore gel eyeliner I have purchased and I didn’t like it. I picked the one in Eggplant to add variety on my liners. This product does not lasts long and is difficult to apply since the consistency is a bit dry. I used this product maybe twice or trice and never used it again. I’m not going to repurchase and would give this a 1 out of 5 score.

*Clinique Cream Liner

I picked the one in True Black and was very impressed when I first applied it. This product is long-lasting, does not crease and does not smudge. The consistency is very creamy which made it easy to apply. I highly recommend this product and would give it a 5 out of 5 score.

*E.L.F  Gel liner

I have a mix feelings about this product. I love the intensity of the color and how it last a long time. It also does not smudge which is a plus but then the consistency is a bummer. When I first use it, it was a bit oily which made it very difficult to apply and then it became dry after just a few weeks. If e.l.f would use an ingredient that would make this product last longer I would probably repurchase. I will give this a 3 out of 5 score.

*H&M Gel Eyeliner

I already made a little review about this product on my previous post (H&M Cosmetics) but I would still like to include it on this post. This is my favorite among all of the five liners. I love the intensity of the color and the consistency which is why it is very easy to apply. It also lasts long and does not smudge or crease. I would recommend this liner and would give it a 5 out of 5 score.

Have you tried any of these liners? What gel liner would you recommend?

Thank you for dropping by!



Follow me on:

Facebook   Instagram   Twitter    Bloglovin’



Much love❤️❤️💋💋,

Arlene Kischaen Aboli


Posted by

Hello! Welcome to thatgirlArlene! I created this blog to share my love for fashion, beauty, style, travel and literature. My goal is to encourage everyone to pursue and embrace the things that you're passionate about, to chase your dreams and to simply love life. ThatgirlArlene is my own penned fairy tale about this adventure called life.

4 thoughts on ““Gel Eyeliner Battle: Product Review”

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s